Security Bits logo - a green padlock with the words Security Bits to the right and in tiny letters below ithat it says 10101010 indicating a digital lock

Security Bits — 22 November 2026

Feedback & Followups

Listener Questions

  • None this time — don’t be shy!

Deep Dive — Apple Detail the up-coming Full Disk Access Changes

Just a few weeks after warning developers that a change was coming to how macOS grants full disk access to apps, Apple have revealed the details. The changes are live in the latest developer betas of macOS 27.3, and Apple have already published a support document describing the new behaviour.

In macOS 27.2 we have two relevant permissions:

  1. Full Disk Access — for reading and writing files and folders.
  2. Device Control and Data Access — for controlling apps, reading the screen, reading the text in open windows, etc.

In macOS 27.3, Apple is splitting the old Device Control and Data Access into two distinct permissions, so we’ll now have three permissions

  1. Full Disk Access — for reading and writing files and folders.
  2. Accessibility — for just the accessibility-related information and abilities like access to the information on screen, the content of open windows, and the ability to type and click.
  3. System & App Protection Override — for fully controlling other apps and accessing all their data.

Apple have also added and updated the prompts users get, and, given users the power to give fine-grained responses. The old Full Disk Access was an all-or-nothing affair, neither of these two new features are like that — you now have three three choices:

  1. Deny
  2. Allow system-wide
  3. Allow on just specific folders/apps

This is similar to how access to photos already works — the app just asks if it can access your photos, and you choose whether to let it see them all, none, or only specific photos or albums.

If you’re a little confused about what these two permissions mean, here are Apple’s descriptions:

When you give an app Full Disk Access instead of choosing only specific protected folders for it to access, it can bypass system protections and access all of the files on your Mac, including your messages, emails, photos and videos, data from other user accounts, and more. It can read, change, delete, and export this data without asking.

When you give an app System & App Protection Override, you can choose specific apps for it to control. If you allow it to bypass system protections instead, it can fully control your Mac and apps, which allows it to access all of your data. It can also see every window and app, including ones in the background, and capture every keystroke.

The user experience for granting these permissions has also received an overhaul with more descriptive warning text aimed at helping regular users understand just how much access these apps are asking for.

As well as clearer dialogs, Apple are also adding an indicator to the menubar to show users when an app is making use of its permission to control other apps, similar to the indicator for location access, but a little more informative. There’s also a live activity for Macs that have a dynamic island, which is on by default, but can be turned off if you find it too intrusive.

Apple have also released some new guidance for developers, instructing them to update their code to handle the possibility of being granted only partial access. For some apps, like security and backup tools, partial permissions don’t make sense, so Apple have provided a solution for these apps too — there is a new entitlement developers can request for their apps that will allow them to force users to choose between full access or no access. Apple have pre-approved the most popular of these tools for this new entitlement, so apps like Carbon Copy Cloner will continue to work as they do now.

Speaking of preapproval, Apple have also made is clear that all existing grants people have given will remain in effect, sp user won’t get bombarded with loads of prompts after updating to macOS 27.3.

After you upgrade, you can choose to cut down some of your existing grants under Settings → Privacy & Security.

Finally, initial experiences from people using the betas seem positive:

“[T]his overhaul of these settings and permissions is a win. I really like the way that, for apps asking for Full Disk Access, users can now grant access to a list of folders instead. That’s what I mean about these new settings giving users more control.” — John Gruber on daringfireball.net/…

Bart’s Thoughts

All of these changes are positive. Separating accessibility tools into their own clearly named category makes thing a lot clear, the and the new indicator for making it clear to users that an app is actively controlling another app should reduce the spooky action at a distance that I think is going on now, particularly with AI Agents doing more than users might expect.

There’s some Sturm und Drang online about the updated messages being ‘scare sheets’ designed to scare people away from using third-party AI agents, but I don’t buy that conspiracy theory. Apple had a real problem to solve — the Mac is becoming ever more popular, and the user base no longer consists mostly of long-time Mac power users. The assumption that the typical Mac user of 2026 truly understands the implications of granting these permissions doesn’t seem reasonable to me. The warning text is also clear, accurate, and definitely not hyperbolic.

There’s also some grumbling about the indicator that one app is controlling another is too intrusive, but that strikes me as vitally important to achieving Apple’s state goal of increasing transparency. Knowing what you’re agents are up to in real time seems much more like a feature than a bug!

One thing I will say is that I’m disappointed Apple have not used this redesign as an opportunity to give users the option of granting apps read-only permission. There’s no reason this can’t come in a later update, and I’ll certainly be submitting some feedback to Apple to request that change. If you agree, please do the same so Apple can see the demand.

Links

❗ Action Alerts

Worthy Warnings

  • ⚠️ iOS Users: Some timely reminders of why, even in Apple’s safer ecosystem, you should still install as many apps as you need, and no more, and constrain yourself to reputable apps.
  • ⚠️ Google Users: Google to retain Gemini chats for two months even with history off — cyberinsider.com/…
    • As search revenue continues to decline, Google’s business model incentivises the company to row back ever more user privacy, so don’t expect this trend to end any time soon.
    • It is entirely possible to move away from Google, there are alternatives where you get to the the customer instead of the product!

Notable News

Excellent Explainers

  • Apple have released a white paper describing how secure exclaves work in great detail — security.apple.com/…
    • An excellent summary: Apple isolates HomeView camera and mic data with Secure Exclaves — cyberinsider.com/…
    • This explains how both Audio Intelligence on Apple Watches and face and voice recognition on the new HomeView implement their privacy promises
    • The technology is most comparable to the chip-level security features used to enforce the barriers between virtual machines and their host OS on modern servers. Not separate chips, but CPU-enforced separation that runs with a higher level of permissions than the OS (so-called ring zero).

Interesting Insights

  • Bit Defender’s 2026 macOS Threat Report confirms what I’ve suspected, most malware gets onto Macs my exploiting the squishy organic bit — www.bitdefender.com/…
    • Malicious pirated apps remain a problem
    • But ClickFix attacks (tricking users into pasting commands) are the cybercrime success story of the year 🙁

Legend

When the textual description of a link is part of the link, it is the title of the page being linked to, when the text describing a link is not part of the link, it is a description written by Bart.

Emoji Meaning
🎧 A link to audio content, probably a podcast.
❗ A call to action.
flag The story is particularly relevant to people living in a specific country, or, the organisation the story is about is affiliated with the government of a specific country.
📊 A link to graphical content, probably a chart, graph, or diagram.
🧯 A story that has been over-hyped in the media, or, “no need to light your hair on fire” 🙂
💵 A link to an article behind a paywall.
📌 A pinned story, i.e. one to keep an eye on that’s likely to develop into something significant in the future.
🎩 A tip of the hat to thank a member of the community for bringing the story to our attention.
🎦 A link to video content.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top