Siri Logo

Siri is a Jerk — by Jonathan Weinman

Hello and greetings from Massachusetts. My name is Jonathan Weinman. I’m what Allison lovingly refers to as a “norm”.

On a recent episode of the NosillaCast, Allison was lamenting her difficulty with using Siri to consistently open her garage door on command. I, too, have had a not-entirely-fun adventure trying to get Siri to open doors for me.

Let’s start, as always, with the problem to be solved: in my case, I would like Siri to consistently unlock a door on command.

The backstory is that two years ago, as my wife and I were leaving our jobs for retirement, we sold our house and moved into a fancy pants new condo building with a fancy pants security system at the building entrances. The system is called Butterfly MX from a company of the same name, and it has touch screen units at the two building entrances and the secure package room. Unit owners have fobs that open the building entrances plus their units, and unit owners can set a PIN to unlock the building entrances. The system also has an app that will unlock the building entrances and package room, and it doubles as the interface to open the entrances for guests. The app is very responsive to touch controls.

I should stop here to say two things: first, I passionately HATE that I have to carry keys or fobs, and I welcome the day when I can ditch keys entirely; and second, I’m the primary walker of a 12lb. Miniature Schnauzer named Lucy. Lucy believes it is her sworn duty to protect me from all threats, real or imagined, near or far, human or canine or critter, and she is not inclined to consider arguments to the contrary, so wrangling Lucy AND fumbling with fobs or PIN codes is not always easy.

Anyway, back to the story. Shortly after moving in, I was digging around the Butterfly MX app looking for hidden capabilities…and that’s when I discovered that Butterfly MX has Siri integration. I had already been successfully using Siri with CarPlay after our move because I was frequently using Apple Maps to learn how to get around our new Boston suburb.

The condo developer established the names of the doors for the building, and in Butterfly MX these names are static; unit owners record their own phrases for each of the three doors. I set about recording my Voice Phrases for the side door, the front door, and the secure package room, with each phrase using all of the appropriate words for a command that would be easily understood by a three-year-old child. For example, my phrase for the side door was “Siri, unlock the side door”. Easy, right? NOPE! Siri would fail to open the requested door somewhere in the vicinity of 25 to 33% of the time, and that does not include the times I either got tongue-tied or had a frog in my throat.

So I changed my phrases by removing all unnecessary words, but that only slightly improved the situation. My previous example was edited to remove the word ‘the’, resulting in the ever-so-slightly robotic-sounding phrase “Siri, unlock side door”.

This change didn’t improve my success rate, and frequently resulted in Siri telling me “Sorry, I can’t unlock your iPhone”. So I edited further to the following single-word phrases: “Siri, garage”, “Siri, package”, and “Siri, door”.

The first two have worked 95% of the time on the first try, but the third one (“Siri, door”) continued to fail with the same frequency and sadly, that’s the door I use most often, both when walking Lucy and to get to my truck in the parking lot. I tried using “TRUCK” and “PARKING LOT” for the phrase, but that didn’t improve things either. “Truck” had a higher failure rate, perhaps because of its single syllable. “Parking Lot” resulted in Siri finding a parking lot nearby and offering directions the first time I tried it, and it had a high failure rate after that.

Then I got inspiration from the Clockwise podcast! During one of the segments, the discussion had something to do with recovering passwords, and one of the panelists said that it’s not uncommon for people to use “let me in” as a password.

I thought it might work for the pesky side door, so I changed the phrase to “Siri, let me in” and by golly, my success rate improved significantly! Is it 100% consistent with unlocking that door? No. Does it sometimes take two or three, even four tries? Yes. Do I sometimes have to long-press the power button on the phone to wake Siri up? Also Yes. Should I stop faffing about after the second attempt and just enter my PIN or use my fob? Probably yes, but where’s the fun in that?

Overall, using Siri this way has been a fiddly experience. I’m certain there were other phrases I tried that used the word “open” rather than “unlock”, but those were met with the same resistance about unlocking a phone.

Siri is definitely not fond of the echo caused by the hard surfaces of the entrance lobbies, so I speak my incantations just as I am opening the outer door to try to avoid the echo and increase success. At the same time, there are active train tracks shared by Amtrak and the commuter rail a mere 100 feet away, and his highness is rarely bothered by the trains whizzing by as I’m speaking to him. At one point I seriously considered setting the phrase to “if it pleases your highness, let me in”, but that is just too much waste of good breath.

And curiously, when I’m playing one of my handful of podcasts with an ever-so-slight Apple bias, AND I want a door unlocked, it often seems like Siri is listening to the podcast rather than the dulcet tones of my voice. Just this week, Siri actively ignored me while Bart was speaking!

In conclusion, there really isn’t one. My story is just one person’s experience. I’ll probably have to tweak one or more of the phrases over time. Or maybe, just maybe, the promised improvements to Siri will actually make him useful. I’m hoping things improve somewhat with my Siri when I take possession of my iPhone Duo at the end of December, which will replace my trusty yet tired iPhone 13.

I’ve got just one more thing so there is no confusion: my Siri is male, British (Voice-2). It’s like having an incorrigible English butler!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top